This could be the most difficult blog I have ever undertaken! I know, right up front, that I will probably get a lot of backlash for this. The topic is VERY difficult to write about without using stereotypes and words that we don’t necessarily “like” to use, but in order to write it I could not find a way NOT to resort to using the stereotypes. I hope you will read first, and understand I am really trying to explain MY concept of answering this often-asked question. I am not intending to insult or disrespect ANYONE in any way, shape or form. And I have tried to very delicately explain that this is just MY take on this topic, and is NOT the rule, may not be agreeable to anyone else. I am being very basic here, believe me we ALL KNOW there’s more to it than these basics, but for the sake of writing this piece I think I have to keep it to the old basic “stereotypes” for better understanding by a wider audience, please allow me a little lee-way here! I would LOVE to see others write about this question and how they would answer it that is different from my thoughts below.
The last post where i posed the question about Femme-Butch dynamics and the question about “why are Femme lesbians attracted to Butch lesbians, why not just date a man?” has spurred some very interesting and varying comments and input from my readers and Youtube audience. I love it! I like hear other peoples’ opinions and what they might say in return to the same question, opposed to what I would say myself. It’s always great to get different perspectives and angles on any subject that interests me.
I am going to boil down my answer to the question.
My simple answer is “Well, they are both Lesbians, and lesbians are women who are attracted and have intimate, sexual relationships with other women.”
Now the particulars are in the pudding of the question. The “asker” (if asked seriously by someone who truly doesn’t understand the Butch-Femme relationship dynamic and is truly curious for an answer. For sake of argument imagine someone close to you, who you love and respect asking you this question in all seriousness) sees two women, one very feminine, “girly” looking, and one very masculine, rougher, “boyish” looking. He/she wonders “why would a woman would want to be with another woman who LOOKS like a man, why not just be with a man if that’s what you like”. It may sound screwed up to us inside the equation; those in the LGBTQ community, and especially those of us who live the Butch-Femme dynamic daily. But let’s just look at what the “asker” is seeing and why the question isn’t always so “stupid” when asked seriously and with respect.
The “asker” sees the Butch as more of a “man” than as the woman that she truly is. Maybe it is her clothing, perhaps haircut, rougher hands, short nails, and the way she is read as very male much of the time. Maybe it’s the way she talks, the way she carries herself, that Butch swagger, the tattoos, or the steel toe boots. Whatever the “asker” sees that leads them to wonder what woman would be attracted to a woman of Butch identity,
This can and does confuse those who are not part of the LGBTQ community, (and even some who ARE part of our community). What the “asker” doesn’t see are her soft heart, her compassion, her personality, the fact that she IS a woman, has female body parts and has experienced life as a woman – a Butch woman.
The Femme she is dating embodies all of the more “Feminine” aspects of being female. She presents to the world much the same way that most non-Butch women present, as purely woman. She may look “straight” (The old, “oh you can’t be a lesbian, you are too pretty!” scenario), may wear make up and have a well coiffed hairdo, long painted nails and wear much more colorful and stylish clothing.
Femmes love the masculine energy of a Butch woman. They love that she IS a woman, and that she is rough and tumble on the outside, but has a heart of gold, is caring, compassionate, tender, vulnerable to only her, and understands her in ways no other does.
As A Butch myself, I love the Feminine energy of a Femme woman. I love that she likes to look her best, not just for me, but every day when she step out that door. I love that she cries on my shoulder during sappy movies, the way her soft, smooth hand fits so good inside of my rough one. I love the smell of her hair, she chose that scented shampoo just because she knew I would like it – and I would TELL her so. I love that she gets honery, stomps her heels and would fight off the whole population of the women’s rest room just so I could piss in peace. Yes, I could go on, but it’s those opposing forces that drive us as Butches and Femmes into each other’s arms. It’s my need for Femme energy and her need for my Butch energy in the end that brings us together as a unit.
So in the end my basic answer to a serious asker, is that Femmes are attracted to the attributes of masculinity that are embodied by a Butch WOMAN. It’s the fact that she IS a woman that is appealing in her masculinity. It’s the way she has her own style and way of carrying masculinity that particular way that she does. It’s about 2 women loving one another, and their preference is for the more opposite of what they are themselves, because that energy appeals to them; speaks to their soul.
Side notes: Of course we all know that in the end relationships come down to personality and how well the two participants get along. Over our life times our tastes go through a range of changes, morphing into new phases and new likes/dislikes along the way. My example is me….In my 20’s I was very much looking at the prettiest girls, the “10’s” as we used to call them. I was into how a woman looked, I was young, eager and maybe a bit shallow. At 30 I matured. Who cares about a few extra pounds anyway? I began to date women who made me laugh, who I enjoyed the company of and who were not just arm candy. I fell in love with a wonderful, intelligent, witty, cute and sexy woman that I would not have given a second look to at 25! She captured my heart and soul for 14 years…At 50 I am now interested in people; yes mostly very Femme women are my preference. But they have to be intelligent, have a great sense of humor, be tolerant, caring, compassionate, and a dozen other things that I never thought about back in the days of hunting the 10’s. I see the inside goods as well as the wrapping, and I am most interested in a combination of the two – a woman who likes to look her best, and is smart as a whip! (she can even OWN a whip! lol). I don’t think about sex first anymore, I think about what we each have to offer the other in ways of partnership, companionship and THEN sex! 🙂
Femmes
Bravo! Mainely Butch, there is a reason this has not been written about before! You are most courageous to take on this difficult task! I got very excited when I read your first post with the question. I wanted to reply but kept getting confused in my answers and fearful of the backlash of using stereotypes. I love everything about the way you have written this. You first of all are sensitive to the larger audience and providing serious info for the sake of better understanding – what more honorable goal than that! You are completely true to yourself and open which takes humbleness and courage – a winning duo! My personal bigger question has been “what lesbian would want to date a femme woman who looks so “straight” that even butches can’t tell them apart (I refer to an earlier article by BOT who asks femmes to give a clear signal) especially in the manicure department ie eeeek stay away from me with those daggers! My personal preference is masculine feminine). Great blog! sure to generate much thinking and conversation – excellent!
LikeLike
Thank you for the encouragement and support here! I’ve been nervous all morning hoping that I don’t alienate any people that I care about – let alone the strangers bringing the hate! So it was truly great to get your comment first of all to let me know I was not alone in my fear of this backlash. But there was no other way I could see to write it without using the dreaded strereotypes and trigger words, like I did. I worked on a video about the topic and will be posting that on my Youtube channel – perhaps later today – but it’s a hard topic to verbally condense as I need to do on YT. Right now the video stands at 18:45 min and I feel that is just too long to hold the viewer’s attention. Again, thanks and I hope you will stop by again! ~Ang
LikeLike
Hello Mainely Butch,
You address the topic perfectly. The Butch-Femme dance is extremely difficult to articulate to people outside of the LGBTQ community, but you do it well and with sensitivity. I’ve had a hard time discussing this topic with other lesbians who very proudly tell me they dislike labels and do not identify as anything other than lesbian. A femme or a butch, who identifies as such, is simply recognizing the qualities which make her unique, and I find the two together as a unit an incredibly beautiful, complementary whole. When I first came out, I struggled, because I look straight. I wanted the whole world to know that I love women! Now I embrace my femininity and no one makes me feel more feminine, than a handsome admiring butch whose masculine energy I absolutely adore. Thank you for taking the time to address this topic head on.
LikeLike
Thank you for your input here! I appreciate you reading my rambles, and yes this topic is a hard one to discuss on so many levels. Again, Thanks! 🙂 ~Ang
LikeLike
In this Femme’s view, you are spot on:-)
LikeLike
I have never felt so understood.This is it.The complete explanation.Ever since I came out I have only been in the butch-femme dynamic and the question why I date women who look masculine is often asked.And it hurts when it comes from other lesbians especially
LikeLike
this a great read as well impeccably dexplained….
LikeLike